Comments on: Jason Castro, “the Loopster” Departs “American Idol” on May 7th

By: ANNE

ANNE — Sat, 10 May 2008 01:52:48 +0000

I am very glad the “Dred-Man ” is gone. His vocals have been weak and his star-(potential) power, even weaker. Now Idol is down to three real talents - - - I think America will ultimately settle on David Cook, even tho David A. has a better voice….As usual, Connie, your comments make me smile…. :-)

By: Stacey

Stacey — Fri, 09 May 2008 00:18:03 +0000

I liked Carly :(. I wish Carly was still on . She was tons better than Jason. But now…… I’m going to say I like Syeesha best. She’s like a young blooming Whitney Houston. She can improve still with her pitch but she will be good. David Cook is the most original I think, but I don’t like his rocker sounding voice as much. David A. has the best voice but he’s kind of dorky and boring. We’ll see what happens!!!!!

By: Pamela

Pamela — Thu, 08 May 2008 18:43:41 +0000

I missed this elimination episode of American Idol but I saw the performance preceeding it and I felt that Jason was the weakest. In fact, I have felt that he has been the weakest for some time. BRING BACK CARLY! Jason’s songs all sound the same to me. Does that mean he has no range? Maybe. However, I’m not a professional singer so I can’t really say. I like the two Davids best; I have for a long time. I prefer David Cook because along with having a beautiful voice, he is more mature than David A. I like David A very much; his voice is amazing but he is still a boy. What will he be like a five years? I hope (and I believe) that he will still be performing publicly. We all have something wonderful to look forward to.